Carabaccia Fiorentina: The Traditional Tuscan Onion Soup Recipe

Carabaccia fiorentina is a Tuscan onion soup, onions slow-cooked in olive oil and broth, served over toasted bread with pecorino or Parmigiano. It takes about an hour and ten minutes. Here you'll find quantities for 4 people, the method, history, variations and storage.

book now a Cooking Class in the Heart of the Oltrarno

An authentic experience combining nature, cooking and conviviality, just 10 minutes from the Duomo.

Carabaccia, or carabaccia fiorentina, is a Tuscan onion soup: thinly sliced onions cooked slowly over low heat in oil, then in broth, served over a slice of toasted bread with grated pecorino or Parmigiano. It takes just over an hour to make with a handful of ingredients.

Here you’ll find quantities for 4 people, a step-by-step method, the dish’s history and its Renaissance origin, tips for cooking the onions, variations and how to store it.

Recipe card

ItemDetail
Prep time20 minutes
Cook time50 minutes
Resting timeNone
Total timeAbout 1 hour 10 minutes
DifficultyEasy
Servings4 people
CategoryFirst course, soup
CuisineTuscan, Florentine
Cooking methodSautéing and simmering in broth

Ingredients for 4 people

  • 1 kg (2.2 lb) yellow or red onions
  • 4 tablespoons extra virgin olive oil
  • 1 L (4 cups) vegetable or meat broth
  • Salt and pepper to taste
  • 4 slices stale Tuscan bread
  • 60 g (2/3 cup) grated Tuscan pecorino or Parmigiano Reggiano

The onions. Slice them thinly and cook slowly over low heat: they should wilt and soften, not brown. It is the long cooking time, more than the amount of fat, that brings out their sweetness.

The bread. Unsalted Tuscan bread, well toasted, soaks up the broth without falling apart too quickly.

How to make carabaccia fiorentina

  1. Slice the onions. Cut them very thinly.
  2. Soften them. Cook them in the oil over low heat for 25-30 minutes, stirring often, until soft and golden, without letting them brown.
  3. Salt and add the broth. Salt lightly, pour in the hot broth, cover and simmer over low heat for 30 minutes.
  4. Adjust the seasoning. Taste and adjust salt and pepper.
  5. Toast the bread. Warm or toast the bread slices and place them in the bowls.
  6. Finish and serve. Pour the hot soup over the bread, sprinkle with grated pecorino or Parmigiano and serve right away.

History and tradition of carabaccia

Carabaccia is an onion soup of Florentine tradition. A recipe considered the dish’s forerunner, in a sweet-and-sour version with crushed almonds, vinegar or wine and sugar, is attributed to the 1500s, to the cookbook of the Italian cook and steward Cristoforo da Messisburgo: the almond-and-sugar version is largely abandoned today in simpler family preparations based on just onions, broth and bread.

A popular story holds that Catherine de’ Medici brought the carabaccia recipe to France, giving rise to French onion soup. This is a widely repeated tale, but it is not documented by primary historical sources: scholarship on Renaissance food history has questioned several culinary anecdotes attributed to Catherine de’ Medici, noting that they remain largely oral tradition rather than established fact. For that reason, this article treats the story of its journey to France as a popular legend, not as verified history.

Practical tips

  • Low heat, long time. The onions must soften slowly: high heat browns and bitters them.
  • Vegetable broth for a lighter version. Meat broth gives more body, vegetable broth keeps the onion flavour in front.
  • Toast the bread well. It soaks up the broth without falling apart too quickly in the bowl.
  • Pecorino for a bolder flavour. Parmigiano gives a more delicate result, Tuscan pecorino a saltier one.
  • Better the next day. As it rests, the onions keep releasing flavour into the broth: you can make it ahead and reheat it before serving.

Variations and storage

Variations

The Renaissance version of carabaccia had a sweet-and-sour contrast, with crushed almonds macerated in vinegar or wine and a spoonful of sugar or honey added to the softened onions. Some families today add a poached egg to the bowl, others finish the soup under the broiler with a generous handful of melted cheese over the bread, in a version visually closer to French onion soup.

Storage

The soup made of just onions and broth, without bread, keeps in the refrigerator for 2-3 days and can be frozen for about a month. Add the bread only when serving, so it doesn’t fall apart during storage.

Frequently asked questions about carabaccia

What is carabaccia?

It’s an onion soup of Florentine tradition, onions cooked slowly in oil and then in broth, served over toasted bread with grated cheese.

Is carabaccia really the origin of French onion soup?

It’s a widely told story, linked to the name of Catherine de’ Medici, but it is not documented by primary historical sources: it should be treated as an oral-tradition legend, not an established fact.

What onions are used for carabaccia?

Yellow or red onions, thinly sliced. The recipe doesn’t call for a specific variety, but sweeter onions give a milder result.

Can you freeze carabaccia?

Yes, the soup without bread freezes for about a month. Add the toasted bread only after reheating it.

More Tuscan soups

For other bread-and-vegetable soups of Tuscan tradition, you can follow the recipe for acquacotta maremmana or for pappa al pomodoro. To learn this and other traditional Tuscan recipes, Orto San Frediano runs cooking classes in Florence.