Brutti ma Buoni: The Tuscan Almond Cookie Recipe

Brutti ma buoni are irregularly shaped cookies of whipped egg white, sugar, hazelnuts and almonds, slow-baked until golden. They take about an hour. Here you'll find quantities for 6 people, method, history and storage.

book now a Cooking Class in the Heart of the Oltrarno

An authentic experience combining nature, cooking and conviviality, just 10 minutes from the Duomo.

Brutti ma buoni (“ugly but good”) are irregularly shaped cookies, with no set form, made from whipped egg white, sugar and a coarse mix of toasted hazelnuts and almonds, baked slowly at a low temperature until golden, crisp outside and soft inside. The name describes the cookie exactly: rough-looking, but assertive in its caramelised, nutty flavour.

Here you’ll find quantities for about 20 cookies, how to whip and cook the meringue with the nuts, oven baking times, the disputed history of this sweet, tips to keep it from sticking to the tray, variations and how to store it.

Recipe card

ItemDetail
Prep time20 minutes
Cook time35-40 minutes
RestingNone (cool completely on the tray)
Total timeAbout 1 hour
DifficultyMedium
Servings6 people (about 20 cookies)
CategoryDessert
CuisineTuscan
Cooking methodStatic oven

Ingredients for 6 people

  • 3 egg whites (about 90 g)
  • 250 g (1 1/4 cups) granulated sugar
  • 40 g (1/3 cup) toasted hazelnuts, coarsely chopped
  • 40 g (1/3 cup) almonds, coarsely chopped
  • A pinch of salt
  • Grated zest of 1/2 lemon (optional)

The chopped hazelnuts and almonds, not too fine, give the cookie its irregular, crunchy texture: the Tuscan version combines both nuts, while other regional traditions use only hazelnuts. The egg whites should be at room temperature, as they incorporate air more easily.

How to make brutti ma buoni

  1. Chop the nuts. Lightly toast the hazelnuts and almonds in a non-stick pan if not already toasted, then chop them coarsely with a knife: you want recognisable little pieces, not flour.
  2. Whip the egg whites. Whip the egg whites with a pinch of salt to soft peaks using electric beaters, then add the sugar a little at a time, continuing to whip until the mixture is glossy and firm.
  3. Cook the meringue in a pan. Pour the mixture into a non-stick saucepan and cook over low heat, stirring constantly with a wooden spoon, for 8-10 minutes: it will turn darker, glossy and thick, almost like glue.
  4. Fold in the nuts. Remove from the heat and immediately fold in the hazelnuts, almonds and, if using, the lemon zest, mixing well.
  5. Shape the cookies. Using two spoons, scoop portions of the mixture and drop them in irregular mounds onto a parchment-lined tray, spaced apart: don’t smooth or shape them, they should stay rough.
  6. Bake slowly. Bake in a preheated static oven at 140°C (285°F) for 35-40 minutes, until the cookies are golden and dry on the surface: at this temperature they dry out more than they bake.
  7. Let them cool completely. Don’t remove them from the tray while warm: they firm up and release easily only once fully cooled.

History and tradition of brutti ma buoni

The origin of brutti ma buoni is disputed, and no source settles the question with certainty. Several Italian towns claim to have invented them: Prato and Pistoia, in Tuscany, where the cookie is said to have been made as early as the early twentieth century with lemon-scented almonds; but Gavirate, in Lombardy, and Borgomanero, in Piedmont, also appear among the proposed origins according to the Italian reference entries that discuss the question. A somewhat similar recipe, the “fave dei morti” described by Pellegrino Artusi in his late-nineteenth-century cookbook, is sometimes cited as a possible precursor, though with a different dough.

Since no document attributes the recipe with certainty to a single town, this article presents the history as an open dispute between different regional traditions, not as a settled fact. The Tuscan version, with almonds (often alongside hazelnuts) rather than the hazelnuts-only versions from Piedmont or Lombardy, is the one followed in this recipe.

Practical tips

  • Keep stirring in the pan. If you stop stirring even for a few seconds while cooking the meringue, the mixture can stick and burn on the bottom.
  • Don’t chop the nuts too fine. A coarse chop, with pieces of varying size, gives the characteristic crunchy texture: too fine and the cookie loses its character.
  • Don’t smooth the mounds. The irregular shape isn’t a flaw to fix: it’s part of the cookie’s identity, hence the name.
  • Low, steady heat. An oven that runs hot will darken the surface before the inside dries out: if yours runs hot, drop to 130°C (265°F) and bake a little longer.
  • Parchment, not a greased tray. Parchment paper keeps the cookies from sticking, especially since they contain little fat compared with an ordinary cookie dough.

Variations and storage

Variations

The Piedmontese and Lombard versions use only hazelnuts, no almonds. Some recipes add a teaspoon of honey along with the sugar for a rounder flavour, or a drop of vanilla extract. Using only almonds instead of hazelnuts brings the flavour closer to amaretti, though the texture stays different.

Storage

They keep for 1-2 weeks in a tin or an airtight container, at room temperature and away from humidity, which would soften them. Freezing isn’t recommended: the cooked meringue tends to lose its crisp texture once thawed.

Frequently asked questions about brutti ma buoni

Why are they called “brutti ma buoni” (“ugly but good”)?

Because of how they look: with no shaped form, each cookie is different from the next, with an irregular, crackled surface. The name plays on the contrast between the rough appearance and the assertive, caramelised flavour.

Why did my cookies stay soft instead of crisp?

Almost always because of too short a bake, or an oven running hot enough to darken the surface before the inside dried out. Try baking a few minutes longer at a slightly lower temperature, and let them cool completely before judging the texture: they firm up as they cool.

Did they really originate in Prato?

Not with certainty: Prato and Pistoia are among the towns that claim the origin, but the same sources that discuss the question also mention Piedmont and Lombardy as possible birthplaces. No document settles the matter.

Can I use only hazelnuts or only almonds?

Yes: the hazelnuts-only version is the most common in Piedmont and Lombardy, while an almonds-only version brings the flavour closer to amaretti. Either way, keep the total amount of nuts at 80 g.

More Tuscan almond sweets

If you like the flavour of toasted almonds, try Tuscan amaretti, soft and almond-scented, or ricciarelli di Siena, flourless oval sweets flavoured with orange. To learn to make Tuscan sweets and biscuits in person, Orto San Frediano runs cooking classes in Florence.