Pici Cacio e Pepe: The Creamy Tuscan Recipe

Pici cacio e pepe are hand-rolled Tuscan flour-and-water noodles dressed with a cream of aged pecorino, pasta cooking water and toasted black pepper. They take under two hours, pici included. Here you'll find quantities for 4 people, how to shape pici, the technique for a lump-free sauce, the history, variations and storage.

book now a Cooking Class in the Heart of the Oltrarno

An authentic experience combining nature, cooking and conviviality, just 10 minutes from the Duomo.

Pici cacio e pepe are pici, thick hand-rolled Tuscan noodles made from flour and water, dressed with a cream of aged pecorino melted into the pasta cooking water and plenty of toasted black pepper. It is a dish of few ingredients where technique matters: the cheese has to melt into a smooth sauce that coats the pasta without forming lumps.

In this article you’ll find quantities for 4 people, the dough and how to shape the pici, a reliable method for the pecorino cream, which cheese to choose, the history of the dish around Siena, variations and how to store raw pici.

Recipe card

ItemDetails
Preparation1 hour
Cooking6-8 minutes
Resting30 minutes (dough)
Total timeAbout 1 hour 40 minutes
DifficultyMedium
Servings4 people
CategoryFirst course
CuisineTuscan, Sienese
Cooking methodBoiling and tossing in a pan

Ingredients for 4 people

For the pici

  • 400 g Italian type 0 soft wheat flour (or 300 g type 0 flour and 100 g fine durum wheat semolina)
  • 200 ml lukewarm water
  • 1 tablespoon extra virgin olive oil
  • 1 pinch of salt
  • Fine durum wheat semolina, to taste, for dusting

For the sauce

  • 160 g aged pecorino, finely grated
  • 2 teaspoons black peppercorns (about 5 g)
  • Pasta cooking water, to taste
  • For cooking: 4 l water and 25 g coarse salt

The pecorino. You need an aged pecorino, savoury and dry, grated very finely so that it melts quickly. In the Val d’Orcia the local pecorino is used, such as the one from Pienza; pecorino romano gives a saltier, sharper result. A young or semi-aged pecorino turns stringy instead of creamy.

Pepper and water. Crush or coarsely grind the peppercorns just before using and toast them in the pan to release more aroma. The starchy cooking water is what binds the sauce: that’s why the pici are cooked in less water and with less salt than usual, since pecorino is already salty.

How to make pici cacio e pepe

  1. Make the dough. Heap the flour into a well, add the salt, oil and, little by little, the lukewarm water. Knead for about 10 minutes until smooth, firm and elastic.
  2. Rest. Wrap the dough in cling film and leave it to rest for 30 minutes at room temperature.
  3. Shape the pici. Roll the dough with a rolling pin to about 1 cm thick and cut it into 1 cm strips. Roll each strip on the board with your palms, from the centre outwards, into long noodles 3-4 mm thick. Lay them on a tray dusted with semolina.
  4. Cook the pici. Bring 4 l of water to the boil, add 25 g coarse salt and cook the pici for 6-8 minutes, depending on thickness. Taste: they should stay al dente.
  5. Toast the pepper. While the pasta cooks, crush the pepper in a mortar or grind it coarsely and toast it in a wide dry pan for a minute until fragrant. Add a ladle of cooking water and let it simmer.
  6. Make the pecorino cream. In a bowl, mix the pecorino with 3-4 tablespoons of cooking water left to cool slightly, until you have a thick, smooth paste. The water must not be boiling: above about 65 °C (149 °F) the cheese seizes into lumps.
  7. Toss off the heat. Drain the pici straight into the pan with the pepper and toss for a minute. Turn off the heat, wait a few seconds and add the pecorino cream, mixing quickly with tongs. Add cooking water a spoonful at a time until the sauce is creamy and glossy.
  8. Serve. Plate immediately, with a grinding of pepper and a little grated pecorino.

History and tradition of pici cacio e pepe

Pici are the homemade pasta of the province of Siena, especially the Val d’Orcia and Valdichiana: just flour, water and salt, no eggs, stretched by hand by rolling them on the board. For centuries they were the Sunday dish of farming families, dressed with whatever was in the house: aglione garlic sauce, fried breadcrumbs, meat ragù.

The cacio e pepe dressing belongs above all to the Roman tradition. Around Siena it was adopted with the local cheese, the pecorino from the hills around Pienza, and has become one of the most common ways to serve pici in the area’s trattorias.

Practical tips

  • Grate finely. Coarsely grated pecorino melts poorly and tends to go stringy.
  • Never cheese over the flame. The cream is made off the heat: direct heat separates the proteins from the fat and the sauce turns grainy.
  • Starchy water. Cooking the pici in less water makes it cloudier and better at binding. Set aside a cupful before draining.
  • Even thickness. If some pici are much thicker than others they won’t cook evenly: re-roll the thickest ones.
  • Serve at once. The pecorino cream thickens as it cools, so bring the plates to the table as soon as they are ready.

Variations and storage

Variations

With ready-made dried pici the recipe is the same: only the cooking time changes, so check the packet. Some trattorias use half pecorino and half Parmigiano Reggiano for a milder sauce that emulsifies more easily. Some cooks also add a knob of butter to the pan with the pepper, which makes the cream more stable but moves away from the essential version.

Storage

Pici cacio e pepe should be eaten as soon as they are made: reheated, the sauce splits. Raw pici, well dusted with semolina and covered, keep in the fridge for a day; for longer, freeze them spread out on a tray and then transfer them to a bag, for about a month. Cook them from frozen, adding a couple of minutes.

Frequently asked questions about pici cacio e pepe

Which pecorino should I use for pici cacio e pepe?

An aged, dry pecorino. Around Siena the local cheese is used, such as pecorino from Pienza; pecorino romano gives a saltier result. Avoid young pecorino, which goes stringy.

Why does cacio e pepe go lumpy?

Because the cheese got too hot. It happens when pecorino is added with the pan on the heat or with boiling water. Make the cream with warm water and toss off the heat.

How long do fresh pici take to cook?

Usually 6-8 minutes once the water returns to the boil, depending on thickness. Dried pici take longer, as indicated on the packet.

Can I use spaghetti instead of pici?

Yes, the sauce is the same, but the dish changes: thick, porous pici hold more of the cream and have a chewier texture.

More Tuscan first courses to try

For more on the dough and shaping, you’ll find every step in the homemade pici recipe, with the traditional aglione sauce. If you prefer egg pasta, start from fresh egg pasta to make pappardelle with wild boar ragù or pappardelle with porcini mushrooms. Rolling pici by hand takes some practice: in Orto San Frediano’s cooking classes in Florence you learn to shape them on the pastry board.